Private Peaceful by Michael Morpurgo

Six of us sat down to discuss this lovely story at our book group this month and focused conversation flowed for quite a while (i.e. we usually deviate from the subject far more!).

We read this book alongside the media run up to the remembrance day for the start of the Great War. Our timing made the story even more profound than it already is.

The story is of a rural family to whom more than a fair share of life challenges had already been presented. Two sons leave to fight in WW1 and one of them finds himself in a situation that commands reflection on his life and relationships.

Michael Morpurgo writes for young people and his outstanding talent has produced a beautiful simple story. The reader experience will depend on their personal life experience but the basic story is one that will appeal to any age from young teenage upward. 

We questioned how the generation of young men, that Tommy and Charlie represent, were able to trust anyone in authority ever again after the experiences they had in this war? (With reference particularly to The Colonel and Sergeant Hanley who fail to meet the expectations of responsible authority that most ordinary people would reasonably have had.)

We  reflected on how strong the women were in the story and how their influence was brought to bear. The brave, open-minded, mother; the wicked, self-interested Grandma Wolf/Wolf Woman, Molly’s mother with her fixed views and closed mind, Molly who despite her mother held on to what was important to her and the feather bearing old woman whose one comment defined Tommy’s destiny.

Many adult readers will have their own handed down family stories of this terrible conflict and we wonder if that is why Michael left an open ending. The reader can choose to decide for themselves what happens next for the characters in the story. 

Would we recommend it? That's a unanimous ‘oh yes’ and we do so without hesitation. This is a must read and we will all read it again (and again!)  

Our next book - Every Day is For the Thief by Teju Cole - is set in Lagos, Nigeria. We will meet to discuss our thoughts on this read on Thursday 15th January 2015, 8pm at the Ashendon Hundred. So why not make more reading a New Year resolution and come and join us?