Whale Fall by Elizabeth O'Connor

Eleven of us met to discuss Whale Fall and, as always, the conversation took us in some unexpected directions.

When a whale dies at sea, it slowly sinks to the ocean floor, becoming the centre of an entire ecosystem. This whale, however, does not fall – it is stranded on the beach, beyond saving, and is left by the small island community to die and decompose.

We spent some time discussing this. Why were the islanders so drawn to the whale, yet made no attempt either to save it or use it for food? We concluded that this reflected the realities of island life and the community's acceptance of the natural order. Some of us also wondered whether the whale itself was an allegory for the island – isolated, slowly declining and clinging on despite an uncertain future. Others felt the whale was there as a timeline or a parallel to the unfolding story. 

Opinions on island life were divided. Some of us found it enchanting, while others found it bleak. Comments ranged from, "I could have happily lived there – I was born in the wrong era!" to, "I found it rather depressing; it left me feeling quite low."

Whatever our feelings about the setting, we all agreed that Elizabeth O'Connor's writing is beautifully evocative. It is a quiet, slow-moving novel, but one that completely immerses the reader. We liked the short chapters, which made the book easy to dip into and kept the story moving despite its gentle pace.

Set during the final four months of 1938 on a tiny island just a few miles off the Welsh coast, the story follows 18-year-old Manod, who lives with her fisherman father and younger sister, Llinos, who speaks only Welsh and is described as being almost "half-elf". Their mother died several years earlier, and her story is revealed only towards the end of the novel, adding another layer to the family's history.

Manod has taught herself English from magazines and has a talent for embroidery, but beyond that her experience of the world is limited. Having spent her whole life on the island, she is sheltered, naïve and vulnerable.

The beached whale brings unexpected visitors: Edward and Joan, two anthropologists from Oxford University. They employ Manod to help with their research, but none of us warmed to them. We felt they exploited both Manod and the islanders, manipulating situations to make the community appear more mysterious and exotic to enhance their own work, with little regard for the consequences for those whose lives they were documenting.

Life on the island revolves around the church, its traditions and its close-knit community. We were particularly fascinated by the tradition of the Mari Lwyd. Yet change is inevitable. The population is no longer sustainable, young people are already leaving, and the looming threat of the Second World War raises fears of occupation. Manod herself begins to wonder whether her future lies beyond the island.

Several of us reflected on how remarkable it is that a place lying only a few miles from the mainland could feel so isolated.

Our discussion also turned to other remote island communities that some members have visited, particularly the Blasket Islands, abandoned in 1953, and St Kilda, whose final residents left in 1930, famously having to drown their sheepdogs before boarding the evacuation boat. Both provide poignant reminders of communities that ultimately became unsustainable, much like the future we sensed awaited Manod's island.

Would we recommend this book? Yes - it is interesting and gives an insight into community and social history. The writing is great. 

Elizabeth O'Connor has spoken in interviews about both the novel and its setting. When asked to describe Whale Fall in just three words, she chose Wild, Atmospheric and Elegiac. Having discussed the book, it's hard to disagree.

Click here for an interview with Elizabeth.

Book Choices July 2026

 The Names by Florence Knapp

It is 1987, and in the wake of a great storm, Cora sets out with her young daughter to register the birth of her son. Her husband expects her to follow tradition and call the baby after him - but is it right for her child to inherit his name from generations of domineering men? Her choice will shape the course of their lives.

Seven years later, her son is Bear, a name chosen by his sister, hoping he will grow up to be brave and big-hearted. Or he is Julian, the name his mother set her heart on, keen for him to become his own person. Or he is Gordon, named after his father and raised in his cruel image - but is there still a chance to break the mould?

Powerfully moving and full of hope, this is the story of three names, three versions of a life, and the infinite possibilities that a single decision can spark.

One of Us by Elizabeth Day

In this compulsive story of betrayal, old bonds and buried scandals, one British establishment family comes face to face with the consequences of privilege and the true cost of power.

Martin and Ben were friends for decades — best friends, Martin would have said — before the terrible events at Ben’s 40th birthday party tore them apart. So when Martin receives a surprise invitation back into the inner sanctum of the dazzling Fitzmaurice family after seven years of silence, he can’t resist the chance to get his revenge.

Ben has risen through the ranks of power, and is now touted as the next Prime Minister. But Martin can’t help but notice certain flies in the ointment… Ben’s wife, Serena, for instance, whose privileged existence is beginning to feel like a gilded cage. Or their daughter, Cosima, an environmental activist fighting against everything her parents once stood for. Or the disgraced MP Richard Take, determined to make his big comeback. And then there’s Fliss, the Fitzmaurice black sheep, whose untimely death sparks more suspicion than closure. Through their intertwined stories, we see a family – and a nation – unravelling under the weight of its secrets.

With everyone watching, the stage is set for a reckoning. It's time for Martin and Ben to confront what love truly means when everything—family, power, and loyalty—is on the line.

Frankie by Graham Norton

Always on the periphery, looking on, young Frankie Howe was never quite sure enough of herself to take centre stage - after all, life had already judged her harshly. Now old, Frankie finds it easier to forget the life that came before.

Then Damian, a young Irish carer, arrives at her London flat, there to keep an eye on her as she recovers from a fall. A memory is sparked, and the past crackles into life as Damian listens to the story Frankie has kept stored away all these years.

Travelling from post-war Ireland to 1960s New York - a city full of art, larger-than-life

characters and turmoil - Frankie shares a world in which friendship and chance encounters collide. A place where, for a while, life blazes with an intensity that can't last but will perhaps live on in other ways and in other people. But as Frankie's past slowly emerges, her spirit and endurance are revealed as undeniable . . . and unforgettable.

Book Choices May 2026

Book Choices for Spring 2026

Yippee - Book  Group time again. We are meeting on Thursday, 14th May, 8pm at The Ash Tree, Ashendon, to discuss Whale Fall by Elizabeth O’Connor. Here are our choices for our Summer read - have a ponder and be ready with your thoughts on Thursday!

Horse by Geraldine Brooks

Based on the remarkable true story of the record-breaking thoroughbred, Lexington, who became America’s greatest stud sire, Horse is a gripping, multi-layered reckoning with the legacy of enslavement and racism in America.

Kentucky, 1850

An enslaved groom named Jarret and a bay foal forge a bond of understanding that will carry the horse to record-setting victories across the South. When the nation erupts in civil war, an itinerant young artist who has made his name on paintings of the racehorse takes up arms for the Union.

On a perilous night, he reunites with the stallion and his groom, very far from the glamour of any racetrack.

New York City, 1954

Martha Jackson, a gallery owner celebrated for taking risks on edgy contemporary painters, becomes obsessed with a nineteenth-century equestrian oil painting of mysterious provenance.

Washington, DC, 2019

Jess, a Smithsonian scientist from Australia, and Theo, a Nigerian-American art historian, find themselves unexpectedly connected through their shared interest in the horse - one studying the stallion’s bones for clues to his power and endurance, the other uncovering the lost history of the unsung Black horsemen who were critical to his racing success. 

The Retired Assassin's Guide to Country Gardening

Dante is a reluctant assassin trying (and failing) to live a quiet life. He has come to the small coastal town of Te Kohe, New Zealand, for a fresh start in life. But he doesn't want to open a BnB, or save a charming bookshop, or start a romance with a single mother in need of rescuing.

He just wants to forget about his past career (which involved a lot of dead bodies) and have everyone leave him alone. 

Unfortunately for Dante, life has other plans... 

Untold Stories by Alan Bennett

 The astonishing sequel to Alan Bennett's classic Writing Home, updated for   paperback. Untold Stories contains significant previously unpublished work,   including a poignant memoir of his family and of growing up in Leeds,   together with his much-celebrated diary for the years 1996-2004, and   numerous other exceptional essays, reviews and comic pieces. Bennett, as   always, is both amusing and poignant, whether he's discussing his modest   childhood or his work with figures such as Maggie Smith, Thora Hird and   John Gielgud. 

That Bonesetter Woman by Frances Quinn

Book Group Review – Spring 2026

Eleven of us gathered at The Ash Tree to share our thoughts on our Spring 2026 read, That Bonesetter Woman. From the outset, reactions were strikingly mixed, ranging from “awful” to “enjoyable,” with “predictable” and the ever-debatable “feel-good read” (delivered with knowing air quotes) also firmly in the mix. As is often the case, such varied responses made for a lively discussion.

First Impressions and Comparisons

For some, disappointment stemmed from expectations shaped by our previous read, another historical novel, The Art of a Lie by Laura Shepherd-Robinson. Laura’s meticulous research set a high bar, and comparisons were inevitable. The ‘awful’ response to This Bonesetter Woman came from feeling that the book did not align with the literary or historical depth they had hoped for, and this perception influenced their view of the research quality. Frances Quinn's career background, outlined in her author biography, 

A Lighter Reading Experience

Others, however, enjoyed the novel for what it offered: an accessible, fast-paced story that did not demand intense concentration. It was described as an easy, enjoyable read that moved along briskly and provided entertainment without being overly taxing.

Predictability and Themes

A recurring point of discussion was the book’s predictability, with the narrative developments being easy to anticipate as new threads emerged. However, this did not entirely detract from the reading experience. Set in 1750s London, the novel explores the challenges faced by a female bonesetter in a male-dominated medical world. While the prejudice she encounters is unsurprising given the historical context, it is a powerful element of the story. 

The Story and Its Characters

At its heart, the novel follows Durie, a woman who discovers both purpose and satisfaction in treating skeletal injuries. Having learned her skills from her father, a rural bonesetter, she builds a practice in London while navigating social and professional obstacles. Her refusal to compromise her ethics, even in the face of success, was widely admired.

Durie herself was loosely based on the historical bonesetter Sarah Mapp, also known as “Crazy Sally”, which was one of the most warmly received aspects of the book. Portrayed as physically ungainly and unapologetically indifferent to social expectations, she won our respect for her confidence, skill, and integrity. Despite working without the benefit of modern medical tools and education, her intuitive, hands-on approach resonated with many of us; several members remarked that they would happily trust her with their own ailments.

Other characters prompted more divided opinions:

• Lucinda was widely dismissed as frivolous and lacking substance – a “silly cow”. 
• Aunt Ellen sparked debate: was she manipulative or simply protective? The consensus leaned toward the latter, though perhaps with a tendency toward overprotection and occasional misjudgement. Her entrepreneurial spirit and desire for her nieces’ independence were seen positively. 
• Durie’s father divided opinion, with some viewing him as chauvinistic while others saw him as a man trying to accommodate his new wife. 
• Malachy was broadly disliked, though his role in the story felt unsurprising. 
• The doctors were criticised for their lack of ethics, in stark contrast to Durie’s principled approach. 
• George, on the other hand, was universally regarded as a true gentleman. 

Would we recommend this book?

Despite the range of opinions, the group reached a strong consensus: “YES” - while it may not satisfy those seeking rigorous historical depth, it succeeds as an engaging and uplifting read. Many of us agreed we would be open to reading more from Frances Quinn in the future.

Our next read is: Whale Fall by Elizabeth O’Connor. We look forward to meeting again on Thursday, 14th May at 8pm, once more at The Ash Tree, for more stimulating discussion.

Book Choices for Spring 2026

Raising Hare by Chloe Dalton

Imagine you could hold a baby hare and bottle-feed it. Imagine that it lived under your roof and lolloped around your bedroom at night, drumming on the duvet cover when it wanted your attention. Imagine that, over two years later, it still ran in from the fields when you called it and snoozed in your house for hours on end. This happened to me.

When lockdown led busy professional Chloe to leave the city and return to the countryside of her childhood, she never expected to find herself custodian of a newly born hare. Yet when she finds the creature, endangered, alone and no bigger than her palm, she is compelled to give it a chance at survival.

Raising Hare chronicles their journey together and the challenges of caring for the leveret and preparing for its return to the wild. We witness an extraordinary relationship between human and animal, rekindling our sense of awe towards nature and wildlife. This improbable bond of trust serves to remind us that the most remarkable experiences, inspiring the most hope, often arise when we least expect them.

Mrs England by Stacey Halls

West Yorkshire, 1904. When newly-graduated nurse Ruby May takes a position looking after the children of Charles and Lilian England, a wealthy couple from a powerful dynasty of mill owners, she hopes it will be the fresh start she needs. But as she adapts to life at the isolated Hardcastle House, it becomes clear there's something not quite right about the beautiful, mysterious Mrs England.

Ostracised by the other servants and feeling increasingly uneasy, soon a series of strange events will force Ruby to question everything she thought she knew . . .

Simmering with slow-burning menace, Mrs England is a portrait of an Edwardian marriage, weaving an enthralling story of men and women, power and control, courage, truth and the very darkest deception. Set against the atmospheric West Yorkshire landscape, Stacey Halls' third novel proves her one of the most exciting and compelling new storytellers of our times.

Whale Fall by Elizabeth O’Connor

It is 1938, and on an island off the coast of Wales, Manod is trying to imagine her future. Her choices are stark: she must either stay and look after her father's house, in the wild landscape that drove her mother to madness, or marry and leave.

And so, when two English anthropologists arrive on the island, Manod senses the possibility of a thrilling new life. But, as she becomes entangled in their work and their strange relationship, the outside world she had yearned for appears a much darker place than she could ever have imagined.

We will meet at 8pm on Thursday, 12th March at The Ash Tree, Ashendon, to discuss our current book - That Bonesetter Woman by Frances Quinn, and then choose our next read. 

A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles

Six of us met to discuss A Gentleman in Moscow, with many thanks to Isalda for hosting. Everyone enjoyed the book, and four described their initial reaction as “loved it.” It was, quite unanimously, a joy to read.

Feedback from members who were unable to attend closely mirrored the discussion on the night, so we hope this summary reflects the wider group view. Those who had read the novel agreed that it was even better on a second reading, with its detail, humour, and depth revealing themselves more fully over time.

We were struck by how remarkable it is that such a long, rich novel could be written about a man confined for decades to a single building — albeit a very grand one. That feat alone speaks volumes about Amor Towles’s skill and imagination.

Although this is a work of fiction, it is firmly grounded in historical reality. The novel captures the societal upheaval and political shifts of post-Revolutionary Russia with great care. Set between 1922 and the 1950s, it reflects the fate of the landed nobility after 1917 — stripped of titles, property, freedom, and often far worse. While Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov is fictional, the world he inhabits feels meticulously researched and historically credible.

Placed under house arrest in Moscow’s Metropol Hotel in 1922, the Count initially faces the shock of losing his privileged life — including his family suite — and adjusting to drastically reduced circumstances. At first, we worried about him. But it quickly becomes clear that the Count is made of strong stuff, and his character gave us plenty to talk about.

As he moves from the shock of confinement to fully inhabiting his new reality, his strengths become clear. Though stripped of title, wealth, and freedom, he retains his dignity, refusing to compromise his manners, morals, or values. He lives a life defined by decency, culture, and responsibility to others. In return, he earns respect, friendship, family, and love — all within the unlocked doors of what becomes his carefully constructed micro-world.

This micro-world is sustained through routine: daily exercise, visits to the barber, dining, one fruit at breakfast, meaningful work, friendships, and vital connections to the outside world through those who are not confined as he is. 

We drew an interesting comparison with Viktor Navorski, the character played by Tom Hanks in The Terminal. Viktor is stranded in JFK Airport after a political coup renders his visa invalid. Like Count Rostov, he must adapt to confinement, gradually transforming an overwhelming crisis into a liveable, even meaningful, existence. Both characters show resilience, optimism, humility, and a willingness to take on work that allows them to both give and receive kindness. Each makes the world they are trapped in function for them.

Turning back to the novel, we discussed Towles’s depiction of the Bolshevik movement. Rather than direct condemnation, he uses humour and satire to powerful effect. We particularly loved the de-labelling of wine and the ceremony surrounding the bouillabaisse — hilarious examples of how culture survives even when its names are erased. The Count’s careful adaptation of his reduced living space felt like a quiet act of defiance, as did his continued insistence on taste, ceremony, and care.

Other characters illustrate the new regime more starkly — notably The Bishop, promoted beyond his competence due to party loyalty, and ultimately unsuccessful in his attempts to extinguish the Count’s influence. There are also darker moments: the disappearance of those who resist, the suppression of talent, and the unintended consequences of political interference in areas that once worked well, such as farming.

The ending was not what many of us expected, but beautiful. 

We also picked up a new favourite game: Zut alors! a quick-fire naming game played by the Count and Sofia:

• One player calls out a category e.g. “Three green things,” “Three things you’d find in a kitchen,”   “Three things that float,” etc.
• The other player must immediately name three correct examples
• Hesitation, repetition, or an incorrect answer means failure
• When the player fails, the other calls out “Zut alors!”

There’s no formal scoring system — the point is speed, fluency, and fun, not winning.

Our discussion sparked personal memories too, including visits to the USSR/Russia — from a 1970s school trip with lunch at the Metropol and a Kremlin tour, to a 1990s visit promoting a language school, staying in a large hotel overlooking the Kremlin. These reflections added another layer to our experience of the book.

Finally, we wondered whether the novel could — or should — be adapted for the screen. We felt it would need to be a very long film. As it turns out, Paramount+ agreed and produced A Gentleman in Moscow as an 8-part series. The jury is still out on whether we’ll watch it — the consensus being that the book is almost certainly better than anything a screen adaptation could achieve.

Would we recommend this book? Absolutely — yes.

Our next read is That Bonesetter Woman by Frances Quinn. We’ll meet to discuss it at 8pm on March 12th, 2026, at The Ash Tree, Ashendon.

Book Choices to Kick Off 2026

We will meet on Thursday, 22nd January, 8pm at Isalda's home in Brill, to discuss 'A Gentleman in Moscow' by Amor Towles.

Isalda has put directions on the Ashendon Book Group WhatsApp Group.

Here's the choices for our next read:

That Bonesetter Woman by Frances Quinn

It’s usual, they say, for a young person coming to London for the first time to arrive with a head full of dreams. Well, Endurance Proudfoot did not. When she stepped off the coach from Sussex, on a warm and sticky afternoon in the summer of 1757, it never occurred to her that the city would be the place where she’d make her fortune; she was just very annoyed to be arriving there at all.

Meet Endurance Proudfoot: clumsy as a carthorse, strong as an ox, with a tactless tongue and a face she’s sure only a mother could love. Durie wants one thing in life: to become a bonesetter like her father. It’s physically demanding work, requiring nerves of steel, and he’s adamant it’s not a job for a woman.

Strong-willed and stubborn, Durie’s certain that in bonesetting, her big, usually clumsy hands have found their natural calling. So when she’s bundled off to London with her beautiful sister, she won’t let it stop her from realising her dream. As her sister finds fame on the stage, Durie becomes England’s most celebrated bonesetter – but what goes up must come down, and her success may become her undoing.

Inspired by the true stories of two of Georgian England’s most famous celebrities, That Bonesetter Woman is an uplifting tale about finding the courage to go your own way, when everyone says you can’t – and about realising that what makes you different can also make you strong.

Paris Echo by Sebastian Faulks

Here is Paris as you have never seen it before – a city in which every building seems to hold the echo of an unacknowledged past, the shadows of Vichy and Algeria.

American postdoctoral researcher Hannah and a runaway Moroccan teenager Tariq have little in common, yet both are susceptible to the daylight ghosts of Paris. Hannah listens to the extraordinary witness of women who were present during the German Occupation; in her desire to understand their lives and through them her own, she finds a city bursting with clues and connections. Out in the migrant suburbs, Tariq is searching for a mother he barely knew. For him, in his innocence, each boulevard, Métro station and street corner is a source of surprise.

In this urgent and deeply moving novel, Faulks deals with questions of empire, grievance, and identity. With great originality and dark humour, Paris Echo asks how much we really need to know if we are to live a valuable life.

The Cat and The City by Nick Bradley

In Tokyo – one of the world’s largest megacities – a stray cat is wending her way through the back alleys. And, with each detour, she brushes up against the seemingly disparate lives of the city-dwellers, connecting them in unexpected ways.

But the city is changing. As it does, it pushes her to the margins where she chances upon a series of apparent strangers – from a homeless man squatting in an abandoned hotel, to a shut-in hermit afraid to leave his house, to a convenience store worker searching for love. The cat orbits Tokyo’s denizens, drawing them ever closer.