We had a good turnout. Somewhere between eight and ten of us (sorry, I didn't count!), which made for a lively and thoughtful discussion.
The Names is a compelling, cleverly structured novel
that explores how one decision can send a life in three very different
directions. At its heart is a baby boy and the choice of what to call him.
Should he be given Gordon, the traditional family name; Cora's (his mum) preferred
choice; or the wildcard suggested by his big sister, Maia?
From there, the story follows three versions of the boy's
life, each shaped by a different name. We meet him again at seven-year
intervals as he grows from child to schoolboy, teenager, student and young man.
It is an ambitious way to tell a story, and we would have loved to ask the
author how she kept track of the three timelines while writing it!
We spent a lot of time discussing the novel's central question: how much can a name shape a life? Some of us found it difficult to believe that a name alone could have such a powerful influence. However, we agreed that the feelings, expectations and history attached to each name might affect both the child and those around him.
The book also gave us plenty of other questions to consider.
Can a parent bond differently with a child because of the name chosen for them?
Might that name carry certain hopes or expectations? Do people respond to us
differently based on what we are called?
We also wondered how the novel would feel if we read each of
the three storylines from beginning to end, rather than moving between them. We
agreed that it could make for a very different reading experience, although
none of us felt quite ready to try it!
Of the characters, the Irish grandmother,
Cora's best friend Mehri and Felix the vet all came out well in our opinion. Gordon, Cora's
husband, prompted a rather stronger reaction. One member summed up the group's
feelings perfectly: "I wanted to jump into the book and smack him!"
Hear, hear!
Despite the boy's three very different experiences, we felt
that something essential in his character endured. Without giving anything
away, there is plenty here to reflect on long after the final page.
Would we recommend it? Absolutely - 100%. It is challenging and sometimes uncomfortable, but also gripping, thought-provoking and packed with questions to get a book group talking.
We will meet again at the Ash Tree in Ashendon on Thursday 26th November, 8pm, to discuss our current read: The Boy from the Sea by Garrett Carr.